Are there circumstances under which parent should be allowed

Assignment Help Other Subject

Reference no: EM133268082

Read the following three approaches to disestablishment legislatures and courts can adopt.

1. act in the interests of the nonbiological father seeking to be relieved of parental responsibility for a child he did not procreate by allowing disestablishment without consideration of the best interests of the child? Under Maryland law, for example, in proceedings to modify or set aside paternity declarations, a "determination of the best interests of the child in ordering... testing, or in the consideration of paternity, whether original or revised, is inappropriate." "Simply stated, the fact of who the father of a child is cannot be changed by what might be the best interests of the child." Finality of paternity determinations is outweighed by fairness to a man who is not a child's biological father. The "law will not compel one who has stood in the place of a parent to support the child after the relationship has ceased."

2. act in the best interests of the child by maintaining an existing parent-child relationship and not allowing disestablishment? The Vermont Supreme Court has described this position as follows: ... The financial and emotional welfare of the child, and the preservation of an established parent-child relationship, must remain paramount. Where the presumptive father has held himself out as the child's parent and engaged in an ongoing parent-child relationship for a period of years, he may not disavow that relationship and destroy a child's long-held assumptions solely for his own self-interest.... Whatever the interests of the presumed father in ascertaining the genetic "truth" of a child's origins, they remain subsidiary to the interests of the state, the family, and the child in maintaining the continuity, financial support, and psychological security of an established parent-child relationship.

3. act in the best interests of the child by allowing disestablishment on the ground that the child should have the opportunity to know his or her biological father? ... Children have a profound right to know their father. They have an interest in their father's care and companionship... . In certain cases, it will be in the child's best interest to know the father's identity. Moreover, it is in the child's best interest to have the opportunity to establish a relationship with him.

Question: Are there circumstances under which a parent should be allowed to disestablish parenthood? If so, what limits should be placed on the process and why?

Reference no: EM133268082

Questions Cloud

The peculiar forms of american capital punishment : Raise one question that you think the author should address in this article. What is your reason to think so - Identify two important statements/points made

Are there any ways that disaster can be predicted : Are there any ways that disaster can be predicted? In what way? If ever "The Big One" happens tomorrow, is the Philippines prepared? Explain.

Global greenhouse effect : Consider the global 'Greenhouse Effect', where thermal energy from the sun is naturally trapped by 'greenhouse gases' present within the Earth's atmosphere.

What kind of heart failure does patient assessment reveal : Question - What kind of heart failure (which side) does this patient's assessment reveal? What assessment findings support your answer

Are there circumstances under which parent should be allowed : Are there circumstances under which a parent should be allowed to disestablish parenthood? If so, what limits should be placed on the process and why?

What does row-major order mean for 2-d arrays : What does row-major order mean for 2-D arrays? What if you had a 3-D array? What is the offset for a[r][c].

How will you individualize patient care based on research : How will you individualize patient care based on research? Describe the knowledge, skills, and attitudes related to each competency

Why might this be important to readers : LAW 01650 Rutgers University why might this be important to readers, and what does it say about Victorian attitudes toward criminality

Determine three evidence-based education strategies : Question - Determine three evidence-based education strategies that will improve your patient's health literacy

User Account

All Pages