Analyze the case from a moral point of view

Assignment Help Business Law and Ethics
Reference no: EM133301924

Assignment:

Analyze the case from a moral (not necessarily legal) point of view. What do you think Socrates would say?

CASE:

By Divine Command?

In a Law and Order episode entitled "Under God,"11 a priest, Father Hogan, confesses to murdering a drug dealer. His justification? That God told him to do it. The drug dealer had sold drugs to a parishioner, who later died of an overdose, leaving behind a bereaved father. In explaining his actions, Hogan states, "A man was destroying my community, poisoning my neighbors. I prayed for guidance, and the guidance I received was that I should kill him."

Father Hogan's lawyer, Wheeler, files a defense based on Father Hogan's claim that he received direct guidance from God. Wheeler argues that if the jury accepts the existence of God, then they cannot deny a defense that is predicated on that existence. McCoy, the prosecutor, objects that "if a layperson tries to exert a 'God Told Me To' defense, the court would render him incompetent to stand trial." Wheeler retorts: "So, if you talk to God, you're pious; and if he talks back, you're crazy?"

A psychological exam later confirms that Father Hogan is perfectly competent and not at all crazy. And Father Hogan is fully convinced that the instructions he received were authentic.

Reference no: EM133301924

Questions Cloud

What change in haemoglobin-saturation curve would anticipate : With Tore's elevated haemoglobin concentration, what change in his haemoglobin-saturation curve would you anticipate? Why?
Demonstrating the property of consciousness : As you focus your attention on this question, you are demonstrating the property of consciousness. As you read, you are also ignoring possible distractions.
Relationship between agape and philia : Explain how Aquinas explains the relationship between agape and philia. Make sure to explain this in terms of the objects of each.
What is problem involved in the mind-body problem : Which response to the mind-body problem (interactionism, idealism, materialism, biological naturalism, or substantial body-soul unity) makes most sense to you.
Analyze the case from a moral point of view : Analyze the case from a moral (not necessarily legal) point of view. What do you think Socrates would say?
Relation between religion and ethics : Outline Kierkegaard's account of the relation between religion (i.e., a passion for secrecy) and ethics (i.e., a passion for public engagement and justice).
Summary of the humor hack : Please provide a summary of from "The Humor Hack." Each chapter please have it detailed so I can understanding each part of it.
Elements of the romantic ideal : Describe in detail (don't just list them) the basic elements of the Romantic ideal. Give specific examples of how these ideals were expressed in art, music.
What is lockes view of the mind : What is Locke's view of the mind? Does he believe in innate ideas? How does the mind relate to things in the world?

Reviews

Write a Review

Business Law and Ethics Questions & Answers

  Legal environment of business caselet

The assignment in Law deals with the topic "Legal Environment of Business". A case study about Mary, a newly joined employee who is working in the USA and Europe. She faces few issues at her work place in Europe and tries to talk to her manager who s..

  Business ethics & legal issues caselet

This assignment is about the concept of Business Ethics & Legal Issues. The laws relating to these can be found in Antitrust laws. These laws are concerned with those large corporations which have a majority of market share, mergers and acquisitions.

  Questions on business law and ethics

Examples of securities that are exempted from the registration provisions of the 1933 Act and involving misstatement of material facts in a prospectus.

  Discuss the doctrine of ratification of pre-incorporation

With the aid of a decided cases, discuss the doctrine of ratification of pre-incorporation contract.

  Discuss the extent of phoenixing activity

It has been estimated that about 6,000 phoenix companies operate in Australia, costing government and the community hundreds of millions of dollars per year and impacting on individuals.

  Application of law to facts

Company Law, Application of Law to Facts and Conclusion.

  Question on business law and ethics

This assignment related to business law.

  Questions on business law

Answer all the questions under business law.

  Iidentify the issue raised by the facts

Iidentify the issue(s) raised by the facts, identify the relevant legal principles, apply the relevant legal principles to the facts, reach a conclusion.

  Evaluation of software development

Prepare a report and present an evaluation of the subsequent methodologies for software development in terms of cost, resources and time.

  Business value and ethics

Business value and ethics,  Bart agrees to put Sam's Super Bowl champion-ship autographed football in his sports store to sell for $1,500. Sam agrees to pay Bart a 15% commission for selling the ball. If Joe comes in the sports store and offers Bart ..

  Explain what is meant by income by ordinary concepts

Advise what tax consequences arise in respect of the payments.

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd