Analyze relationship between treatment method and outcome

Reference no: EM131405791

The success rates of two treatments (A and B) for clinical depression are being compared. The research team included five doctors, and the participants were 200 patients with depression. The doctors were supposed to randomly assign treatments to patients, but two doctors didn't do this. Instead, they often assigned more severely depressed patients to use treatment A and less severely depressed patients to use treatment B.

a. Three variables measured by the investigators were the outcome of treatment (successful or not), method of treatment (A or B), and a rating of the initial severity of the depression (mild or severe). Which of these variables is the response variable in this investigation?

b. The doctors were surprised by the final result, which was that treatment B had a higher success rate than treatment A. Based on results attained by other investigators, they had expected the opposite to occur. Explain how the actions of the two doctors who did not always randomly assign treatments may have caused an unfair comparison of the two treatments.

c. Taking given Example into consideration, describe how the researchers might control for the effect of the initial severity of patient depression when they analyze the relationship between treatment method and outcome.

Example
Blood Pressure and Oral Contraceptive Use This is a hypothetical example of an observational study done to examine the association between oral contraceptive use and blood pressure. Although the data are hypothetical, they are similar to data from several actual studies of the same problem.

Reference no: EM131405791

Questions Cloud

Analyze the message-the channel and potential for feedback : you will research the different ways that managers and leaders use communication to guide their organizations. Feel free to use the same organization you researched for the Unit VI Case Study. You are not limited to this organization, but it may b..

Does given mean that procrastinating increases illness : A researcher observes that, compared to students who do not procrastinate, students who admit to frequent procrastination are more likely to miss class due to illness. Does this mean that procrastinating increases illness? What is another explana..

Explain the style approach and two general kinds of behavior : Explain the style approach and two general kinds of behaviors. What is the central purpose of the style approach? Respond to at least two of your fellow students' postings.

Describes the small business that you selected : MGT/465- Write a 1,050-word paper that describes the small business that you selected and answer the following questions: What type of small business is it?

Analyze relationship between treatment method and outcome : Taking given Example into consideration, describe how the researchers might control for the effect of the initial severity of patient depression when they analyze the relationship between treatment method and outcome.

What is the median salary of the registered nurses : A survey was conducted to determine the preferred news source for homeowners in Illinois (Television, Internet or Newspaper). 10,000 households were divided by income level and households from each income level were randomly selected to participat..

Write null and alternative hypotheses about sex : Write null and alternative hypotheses about sex and the risk of a lower-extremity injury while playing interscholastic soccer.

Write a two way table of observed counts for sex : Write a two-way table of observed counts for sex and whether a participant in soccer had a lower-extremity injury or not.

Which is strongly related to performance for your company : Compare the difference between job satisfaction and organizational commitment. Determine which is more strongly related to performance for your selected company.

User Account

All Pages