Analyze broad constitutional thought lying behind the issue

Assignment Help Other Subject
Reference no: EM13832337

Criminal law

Word limit: 1250

In Ferguson v Walkley (2008) 17 VR 647, Harper J said (at [1]), "The principles of democratic governance have had difficulty in accommodating laws designed to deal with offensive behaviour - with which I include offensive language."

Later in that same case, Harper J observed (at [5]), "According to Professors Bronitt and McSherry, "criminalising offensive language or conduct has the potential to interfere with the freedom of expression, assembly and association protected by Arts 19, 21 and 22 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights" - and, more relevantly for present purposes - those rights protected by ss 15 and 16 of the Charter of Human Rights and Responsibilities." (citations deleted.)

His Honour was addressing documents that have no direct legislative application in Queensland; nevertheless, the general point he made has substance.

Queensland laws dealing with offensive behaviour were once found in the Vagrants Gaming and Other Offences Act 1931, and can now be found in the Summary Offences Act 2005, particularly at s6. You can find the Summary Offences Act 2005 and commentary in your copy of Carter.

In Theophanous v Herald and Weekly Times Ltd (1994) 182 CLR 104 and Lange v ABC (1997) 189 CLR 520, the High Court found that the Australian Constitution implied certain rights with respect to political speech.

Those cases were about mainstream media publications, but a question arises about the extent to which those ideas extend to less formal methods of conveying ideas that might be thought to have a political dimension.

In Coleman v Power (2004) 220 CLR 1, the High Court considered the effect of the constitutional ideas in Theophanous and Lange on summary offence laws relating to public order. Mr Coleman also litigated related legal issues in Coleman v Kinbacher [2003] QCA 575. (You should not assume that the cases referred to in this question are the only cases on point.)

What limitations, if any, have the High Court and Queensland courts imposed on the power of parliaments to regulate speech where that speech might be thought to be a public order issue, such as speech which s6 of the Summary Offences Act 2005 prohibits? To what extent, if any, has the Queensland Parliament responded after the Coleman decision?

In your answer, you should cite authority for the test to be applied, and describe the content of the test, for deciding whether a provision of the sort exemplified by s6 might or might not be able to be found constitutionally invalid. You should provide examples of cases where this issue has been discussed and determined.

This question does not require you to analyse the broad constitutional thought lying behind the issue of free speech. That is beyond the scope of a course on criminal law. Rather, it requires you, on the basis that the ideas in Theophanous and Lange are accepted, to examine their practical effect on the content of laws such as s6 of the Summary Offences Act 2005.

Reference no: EM13832337

Questions Cloud

What is the term for a system in which the product worked : What is the term for a system in which the product being worked on is physically attached to the line and automatically moved to the next station when the cycle time has elapsed
An academic or business communication issue : How a business report should be structured and why and what is the difference between an acceptable and an unacceptable reference source?
Calculation using venn diagrams : Venn diagrams
Find average interest rates charged by commercial banks : Go to the Federal Reserve Web site, http://www.federalreserve.gov.  Go to "Economic Research and Data," and access "Recent Statistical Releases" and the "Consumer Credit."  Find average interest rates charged by commercial banks on new automobile loa..
Analyze broad constitutional thought lying behind the issue : This question does not require you to analyse the broad constitutional thought lying behind the issue of free speech. That is beyond the scope of a course on criminal law.
What can help prevent issues related to downloading : What can help prevent issues related to downloading
Analyze the underlying factors that led to the cold war : Analyze the underlying factors that led to the Cold War. Identify the origin of the rivalry between the two blocs and explain the potential strengths and weaknesses of the English-speaking world versus the Soviet world in 1946
Adopt a condensing power plant : Adopt a condensing power plant with a feedwater tank (MV) with the wiring diagram and information - High-pressure turbines are isentropic efficiency of 0.88.
Discuss your observations of the man abilities in the video : Watch the following video at: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZMLzP1VCANo Discuss your observations of the man's abilities in the video

Reviews

Write a Review

Other Subject Questions & Answers

  Cross-cultural opportunities and conflicts in canada

Short Paper on Cross-cultural Opportunities and Conflicts in Canada.

  Sociology theory questions

Sociology are very fundamental in nature. Role strain and role constraint speak about the duties and responsibilities of the roles of people in society or in a group. A short theory about Darwin and Moths is also answered.

  A book review on unfaithful angels

This review will help the reader understand the social work profession through different concepts giving the glimpse of why the social work profession might have drifted away from its original purpose of serving the poor.

  Disorder paper: schizophrenia

Schizophrenia does not really have just one single cause. It is a possibility that this disorder could be inherited but not all doctors are sure.

  Individual assignment: two models handout and rubric

Individual Assignment : Two Models Handout and Rubric,    This paper will allow you to understand and evaluate two vastly different organizational models and to effectively communicate their differences.

  Developing strategic intent for toyota

The following report includes the description about the organization, its strategies, industry analysis in which it operates and its position in the industry.

  Gasoline powered passenger vehicles

In this study, we examine how gasoline price volatility and income of the consumers impacts consumer's demand for gasoline.

  An aspect of poverty in canada

Economics thesis undergrad 4th year paper to write. it should be about 22 pages in length, literature review, economic analysis and then data or cost benefit analysis.

  Ngn customer satisfaction qos indicator for 3g services

The paper aims to highlight the global trends in countries and regions where 3G has already been introduced and propose an implementation plan to the telecom operators of developing countries.

  Prepare a power point presentation

Prepare the power point presentation for the case: Santa Fe Independent School District

  Information literacy is important in this environment

Information literacy is critically important in this contemporary environment

  Associative property of multiplication

Write a definition for associative property of multiplication.

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd