3016LAW Constitutional Law Assignment

Assignment Help Business Law and Ethics

Reference no: EM132473775

3016LAW - Constitutional Law - Griffith University

Assignment Question

In Kruger v Commonwealth (1997) 190 CLR 1, while addressing the core issue as to whether or not actions authorised by the Aboriginals Ordinance Act (1918) (the ‘Aboriginals Ordinance') fell within the description of genocide in the Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide (the ‘Genocide Convention'), the High Court of Australia afforded less than sufficient weight to the interpretation and construction of the word ‘care'.

Upon closely reading the majority judgments, as well as the minority (dissenting) judgments, do you agree or disagree with this statement? If so, why? If not, why not?

To answer this Assignment Question, begin by reading Kruger v Commonwealth (1997) 190 CLR 1 ("Kruger"), and then conduct an exercise of characterisation and interpretation by addressing the following points in the order below:

Part 1. First, Characterisation.

• How is the legislation in question - that is, the particular section or sub-section in issue in Kruger - characterised? (Note that the specific legislation in question is the text that contains the word "care".) To assess the characterisation of the legislation in question in terms of its constitutional validity, summarise the head of power of the Commonwealth Constitution that was considered relevant by the judges, any test/s for connection that were applied by the judges, any limits on power that were considered relevant by the judges when characterising the legislation in question, the decision in the case, and the practical effect/s on the plaintiffs.

• What leading decisions were applied in Kruger by the judges, and how?

Part 2. Second, Interpretation.

• How is the Constitution relevantly interpreted by the judges in Kruger in terms of their interpretive approaches? Put differently, how did the judges reach their judgments in terms of constitutional interpretive theory and doctrines?

• In light of this analysis, what do you consider to be the preferable interpretive approach? Did any of the judges in Kruger afford a proper construction to the meaning of the term "care"?

Reading and analysing cases, understanding constitutional method, and constructing arguments, is a critical skill for a constitutional lawyer.

Attachment:- Constitutional Law.rar

Reference no: EM132473775

Questions Cloud

What is the rate variance of direct materials : What is the rate variance of the direct manufacturing labour and the direct marketing labour, respectively? What is the rate variance of direct materials

What are lapareta''s all-in-cost today if libor rises : What are Lapareta's All-in-Cost today if LIBOR rises ( for 0.5% each year) and if LIBOR falls(for 0.5% each year)? (Lapareta uses 12% as its weighted average co

How security measures applied to ksa healthcare initiatives : Describe the security requirements for electronic protected health information (ePHI) by evaluating the HIPAA security administrative, physical, and technical.

Prepare a presentation on staff development : Your staff development PPT presentation will include the information from your written paper in 10-12 slides (including a title and reference slide).

3016LAW Constitutional Law Assignment : 3016LAW Constitutional Law Assignment Help and Solution, Griffith University - Assessment Writing Service - What leading decisions were applied in Kruger

Create and journalize the transactions for watson company : Create and Journalize the transactions for Watson Company using the gross method of accounting for purchase discounts. Assume a perpetual inventory system.

Prepare journal entries to record the partners contribution : After the first quarter of the current year, Joy and Lucy, both proprietors, Prepare the journal entries to record the partners contribution.

What risk-free rate of return should you expect on norwegien : A risk free asset in the U.S. is yielding 4 percent. What risk-free rate of return should you expect on a Norwegian security?

Describe the validity and reliability of the instrument : Describe the validity and reliability of the instrument you chose in and explain how is this different from external and internal validity? (50-75 words)

User Account

All Pages